Answer
Evangelist Billy Graham (1918—2018) and his ministry team developed what’s now known as “the Billy Graham Rule” in 1948. The rule stated that Graham and his colleagues would avoid traveling, eating, or meeting alone with women who were not their wives. Although Graham did not follow the rule legalistically, he generally made sure that any one-on-one meeting with a woman took place in public. Many Christian ministry leaders have followed similar practices. Former U.S. Vice President Mike Pence also became associated with the practice. This led some people to refer to it as the “Mike Pence Rule.”
The rule reflects biblical warnings about sexual temptation. In some situations, it may be impractical or impossible for a man and woman to avoid being alone together. Nevertheless, the Billy Graham Rule can provide a helpful principle for Christians seeking to exercise wisdom and avoid temptation in everyday situations.
The rule was part of a broader set of standards that guided Billy Graham’s ministry. During evangelistic meetings in Modesto, California, in 1948, Graham met with the other men on his ministry team. They discussed several areas in which evangelists could face temptation or lose credibility. In addition to avoiding compromising situations with women, they resolved to emphasize financial accountability. They would also speak respectfully about local pastors and churches and report attendance figures honestly. These principles later became known as the “Modesto Manifesto.”
Graham did not apply the rule without exception throughout his life. One well-known example involved former U.S. First Lady Hillary Clinton, who asked him to speak privately while sitting in a public restaurant. Graham concluded that such an arrangement did not violate the purpose of his practice. Nevertheless, he generally avoided spending private one-on-one time with women other than his wife and became known for exercising considerable caution in this area.
The Bible repeatedly instructs believers to avoid sexual temptation. Paul commanded Christians to “flee from sexual immorality” (1 Corinthians 6:18, ESV). He also told Timothy to “flee youthful passions” (2 Timothy 2:22, ESV). He also reminded the Corinthians that some of them had once lived sexually immoral lives. However, they had been washed and sanctified through Christ (1 Corinthians 6:11). Because sexual temptation is a real danger, Christians should not unnecessarily place themselves in situations that make temptation stronger. The Billy Graham Rule applies this principle by encouraging believers to create reasonable boundaries before temptation arises.
Scripture treats adultery as a serious sin. Under the Old Testament law, adultery could carry the death penalty. Jesus later taught that sexual sin also involves the desires of the heart. He warned that looking at another person lustfully is a form of adultery in the heart (Matthew 5:28). Therefore, Christians should take both sexual sin and the temptation leading to it seriously. Inappropriate attraction can develop even in ordinary settings. Recognizing this possibility helps explain the wisdom of establishing careful boundaries with people who are not one’s spouse.
In everyday life, men and women regularly work and socialize together. Workplace responsibilities may require a man and woman to spend time alone in an office, vehicle, or other setting. Similar situations can arise because of transportation arrangements or unexpected circumstances. In healthcare settings, patients also commonly receive care from providers of the opposite sex. For these reasons, completely avoiding every one-on-one interaction is not always practical.
These situations require wisdom and discernment. Christians should consider both the danger of temptation and how their conduct may appear to others. When possible, one-on-one meetings can take place in public areas or in rooms where other people are nearby. Open offices, glass walls, and other visible settings can provide additional accountability. Careful planning can also reduce unnecessary time alone in vehicles or isolated places. The goal is not to treat every interaction with suspicion but to establish reasonable safeguards that protect purity and preserve a Christian’s testimony.
Overall, the Billy Graham Rule reminds Christians to keep their thoughts and intentions pure. This is especially important when meeting with members of the opposite gender. One-on-one meetings between unmarried men and women may be necessary in certain contexts. When they are, believers can exercise wisdom by choosing appropriate settings and maintaining clear boundaries. Such practices can help Christians avoid temptation, protect their marriages, and maintain a trustworthy testimony before others.
